Autonerdz Home Autonerdz FAQ User’s Comments Autonerdz Events Autonerdz Store Contact Autonerdz

Autonerdz forums

 
  Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
Autonerdz - Since 2000, North America's Authority on PicoScope
 
  HomeHelpSearch Member Map Event CalendarRegisterLogin  
 
Pages: 1 2 3 4
1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob (Read 1,047 times)
RedlinePowersports
Freshman Member
Picogroup
*
Offline


I'm a motorcycle Autonerd

Posts: 47

Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA
Waukesha
Wisconsin
USA

Gender: male
1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Oct 20th, 2017 at 1:46pm
 
Hey guys, been a while since I have posted but I have another stumper that I hope you all may be able to help with.

A guy brought me this bike to Dyno Tune so we ordered him a jet kit and proceeded to tune the bike. The Air/Fuel ratio seemed to pretty much stay the same no matter how much fuel I added or took away. Also something odd that I have never seen...the plugs were white indicating a lean mixture but my AFR was reading nearly 11:1(very rich). My gears got to turning and I thought that this is most likely ignition. The bike is putting down roughly 35 hp. They are roughly 55 hp out of the box. So I am running nearly 20hp shy of factory numbers.

I have a couple of waveforms that I have saved and will attach for you guys to check out. I normally dont like to jump to the most expensive part to replace but I think it may be a possible CDI box failure.

I started with the scope on the secondary side of the coil and have worked my way backwards towards the CDI box. The coils all ohm out within spec on the primary and secondary side according to the service manual. (.2-.5ohms primary side) (35K ohms on the secondary side)

The trigger coils also fall into spec at 523 & 528 ohms.

All wires from the CDI to the coils have been check and show good continuity and have no shorts to ground.

So my thought is that if I have good information/signal going into the CDI box and getting poor signal out...seems like a CDI?

The attached file with the primary coil voltage and secondary voltage are both under load and both seem bad to me. (Don't look like good waveforms) Front and rear coils are almost identical which also points to the CDI because my thought is...what are the odds of two coils failing at the same time?? Undecided

Still not a master at the scope which is why I am asking what you guys think!  Smiley
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
RedlinePowersports
Freshman Member
Picogroup
*
Offline


I'm a motorcycle Autonerd

Posts: 47

Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA
Waukesha
Wisconsin
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #1 - Oct 20th, 2017 at 2:35pm
 
Attached is the dyno sheet.
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
James H
Senior Member
Picogroup
***
Offline


Bike Nerd

Posts: 165

Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
Waterloo
Ontario
Canada

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #2 - Oct 20th, 2017 at 3:11pm
 
Hi, first of all that it is not CDI ignition but Transistorized ignition. You can tell that from your capture. I believe you may have used the wrong probe setting for you secondary leads as the voltage is way too high. Do you have the colored leads and did you by chance select the "black secondary probe" setting? I personally do not see a problem with coil output, primary looks good. The only thing I see is the secondary is suggesting to have a lean condition because of the sloping up of the burn line. Are you using a 4 gas analyzer or a wideband to determing afr? Is 11-1 at wide open top rpm?  If using the 4 gas what is your 02, co and co2 readings. Down that amount of hp I would think would require a dead hole or some major mechanical problems. If you want a quick and dirty test for afr problems stick it on the dyno and do a lean/rich test quickly by opening up the airbox lid slightly (lean) and partially duct tapping off the intake snorkel (rich). Only do enough to make a small change in power output. If it goes up in one of the tests, try slightly more. If it goes up again you for sure have found at least one problem. Can you do an in cylinder compression test? Can you post the Dyno graph?
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
Spence
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline



Posts: 8,025

Jeffersonville, Pennsylvania, USA
Jeffersonville
Pennsylvania
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #3 - Oct 20th, 2017 at 3:18pm
 
James H wrote on Oct 20th, 2017 at 3:11pm:
Hi, first of all that it is not CDI ignition but Transistorized ignition. You can tell that from your capture. I believe you may have used the wrong probe setting for you secondary leads as the voltage is way too high. Do you have the colored leads and did you by chance select the "black secondary probe" setting? I personally do not see a problem with coil output, primary looks good. The only thing I see is the secondary is suggesting to have a lean condition because of the sloping up of the burn line. Are you using a 4 gas analyzer or a wideband to determing afr? Is 11-1 at wide open top rpm?  If using the 4 gas what is your 02, co and co2 readings. Down that amount of hp I would think would require a dead hole or some major mechanical problems. If you want a quick and dirty test for afr problems stick it on the dyno and do a lean/rich test quickly by opening up the airbox lid slightly (lean) and partially duct tapping off the intake snorkel (rich). Only do enough to make a small change in power output. If it goes up in one of the tests, try slightly more. If it goes up again you for sure have found at least one problem. Can you do an in cylinder compression test? Can you post the Dyno graph?


Smiley  Nice!
Back to top
 

N.B.S.   Dilly Dilly!  FJB
WWW WWW spencedecordre  
IP Logged
 
Tom Roberts
Autonerdz Administrator
Picogroup
*****
Offline


Autonerdz Founder

Posts: 8,598

Olympia, Washington, USA
Olympia
Washington
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #4 - Oct 20th, 2017 at 3:45pm
 
James H wrote on Oct 20th, 2017 at 3:11pm:
Do you have the colored leads and did you by chance select the "black secondary probe" setting?


That is exactly what he did.


Russ,

Use the colored secondary probe from your probe library section.  if you have nothing in the library section, install the Autonerdz PicoScope add-on.
Back to top
 

Tom Roberts
Forums Administrator
 
IP Logged
 
RedlinePowersports
Freshman Member
Picogroup
*
Offline


I'm a motorcycle Autonerd

Posts: 47

Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA
Waukesha
Wisconsin
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #5 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 6:45am
 
You are correct it is a TCI rather than a CDI. Tom and James, you were definitely right the settings were wrong. I have changed them to the colored wire secondaries and re run the test. See attached file.

Mechanical problems are fairly ruled out. Compression is even on both cylinders at 150. We have also tried opening the air box and closing it off and other variations of varying the fuel delivery which is why I started checking out ignition. Every combination of fuel change has had no effect on horsepower curve.

I wish I could get you the other information regarding the 4 gas but we are using a wide band o2 from our dyno. I do have a test gas that we use to check our sensors before we do any dyno tuning and both of my o2 sensors check out and have also been swapped around to make sure of an accurate reading.
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
Spence
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline



Posts: 8,025

Jeffersonville, Pennsylvania, USA
Jeffersonville
Pennsylvania
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #6 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 6:59am
 
RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 6:45am:
You are correct it is a TCI rather than a CDI. Tom and James, you were definitely right the settings were wrong. I have changed them to the colored wire secondaries and re run the test. See attached file.


Much better! Do you have other coils you could sway onto this?
Back to top
 

N.B.S.   Dilly Dilly!  FJB
WWW WWW spencedecordre  
IP Logged
 
RedlinePowersports
Freshman Member
Picogroup
*
Offline


I'm a motorcycle Autonerd

Posts: 47

Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA
Waukesha
Wisconsin
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #7 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 7:04am
 
Unfortunately no, I have some other coils laying around but not a direct part number replacement. Do you see a problem with swapping in a different coil from a different bike? If I did, what requirements would I look for in a coil so to not damage the TCI?
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
James H
Senior Member
Picogroup
***
Offline


Bike Nerd

Posts: 165

Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
Waterloo
Ontario
Canada

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #8 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 9:17am
 
Just noticed in your first post you said primary resistance of the coils is .2 to .5 ?. Primary side of the coils should be 2 to 2.5 ohms. Any non CDI (they always have very low pri resistance - read high amperage) coil off any bike will work.
When did the problem start? Since you put in a jet kit? After the customer did some modification? Did it happen suddenly or deteriorated over time. Is it consistent? How much mileage? This will help with a diagnostic direction.

Your peak torque looks about right at 3000 rpm but just falls off too quick. In my opinion I would think a air flow or air fuel ratio problem as an ignition problem I would think would show up at peak torque. Do you have a plugged carb slide vent preventing them from opening?
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
RedlinePowersports
Freshman Member
Picogroup
*
Offline


I'm a motorcycle Autonerd

Posts: 47

Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA
Waukesha
Wisconsin
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #9 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:29am
 
The problem has been there since we got the bike in. We did a baseline for him a few weeks ago and saw the low torque/hp curve. Since the customer has "bobbed" the bike and changed exhaust we naturally assumed the fuel air was wrong so we recommended a tune.

After tuning for some time and seeing very little change on the graph we started troubleshooting the problem. The problem was there before the jet kit and has remained unchanged since the jet kit was installed.

Bike has 27,208 miles. As far as I can tell the bike has had the problem for some time. The customer brought it in originally for a tune saying that he felt that the bike should have more power. He couldn't be more right.  Tongue

Both carb slide are free to move and I have visually confirmed this with the intake boots off while running on the dyno.

If I am not mistaken, isn't the peak voltage on the secondary low? Its right around 4-7k volts. Aren't most coils upwards of 40k volts?
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
Spence
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline



Posts: 8,025

Jeffersonville, Pennsylvania, USA
Jeffersonville
Pennsylvania
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #10 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:54am
 
RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:29am:
The problem has been there since we got the bike in. We did a baseline for him a few weeks ago and saw the low torque/hp curve.


Smart move. We do the same here and it has saved a lot of stress when dealing with a customer. Showing them what they really have vs. what they think they have works wonders!

RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:29am:
Since the customer has "bobbed" the bike and changed exhaust we naturally assumed the fuel air was wrong so we recommended a tune.


This has come up a lot here. Someone thinks a tune is the issue when it's something else.

RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:29am:
After tuning for some time and seeing very little change on the graph we started troubleshooting the problem. The problem was there before the jet kit and has remained unchanged since the jet kit was installed.


We have a saying if you add 10% fuel, take away fuel 10%, add  10 to 15 degrees lead ignition timing and take away 10 to 15 degrees lead ignition timing and little or no response it's not the tune.

RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:29am:
Bike has 27,208 miles. As far as I can tell the bike has had the problem for some time. The customer brought it in originally for a tune saying that he felt that the bike should have more power. He couldn't be more right.  Tongue

Both carb slide are free to move and I have visually confirmed this with the intake boots off while running on the dyno.


Smiley

RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 10:29am:
If I am not mistaken, isn't the peak voltage on the secondary low? Its right around 4-7k volts. Aren't most coils upwards of 40k volts?


You will only see the coil output that high when there is an open circuit either because of an issue or you made it one by pulling a plug wire off and making a larger gap.
Back to top
 

N.B.S.   Dilly Dilly!  FJB
WWW WWW spencedecordre  
IP Logged
 
Spence
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline



Posts: 8,025

Jeffersonville, Pennsylvania, USA
Jeffersonville
Pennsylvania
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #11 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 11:13am
 
I have also noticed on your primary voltages you are reading negative. Just how are you hooking up your leads?
Back to top
 

N.B.S.   Dilly Dilly!  FJB
WWW WWW spencedecordre  
IP Logged
 
RedlinePowersports
Freshman Member
Picogroup
*
Offline


I'm a motorcycle Autonerd

Posts: 47

Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA
Waukesha
Wisconsin
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #12 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 12:00pm
 
Just putting the curved clamp on the plug wire and the ground wire to the chassis of the bike.
Back to top
 
WWW WWW  
IP Logged
 
Spence
LSD Guide
Picogroup
*****
Offline



Posts: 8,025

Jeffersonville, Pennsylvania, USA
Jeffersonville
Pennsylvania
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #13 - Oct 21st, 2017 at 12:15pm
 
RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 21st, 2017 at 12:00pm:
Just putting the curved clamp on the plug wire and the ground wire to the chassis of the bike.


Tell us how you have the primary traced hooked up please.
Back to top
 

N.B.S.   Dilly Dilly!  FJB
WWW WWW spencedecordre  
IP Logged
 
StitchB
Super Nerd
Picogroup
*****
Offline



Posts: 1,314

lake stevens, Washington, USA
lake stevens
Washington
USA

Gender: male
Re: 1996 Honda Shadow 1100 with possible ignition prob
Reply #14 - Oct 23rd, 2017 at 4:32am
 
RedlinePowersports wrote on Oct 20th, 2017 at 1:46pm:
the plugs were white indicating a lean mixture but my AFR was reading nearly 11:1(very rich).


Good thread, but one quesiton?, how is the AfR determined, is this with a scanner or what?  11/1 verses White plug, someone is not telling the truth and it is not the plug, don't need a Pico or scanner for that, but suppose timing could do that.  Is this unit injected or old school float ect?

After liestening to James, hate too say too much and sound stupid, he is all over this, James, as Spence stated I second Nice.

Stitch





Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 4